Compare STR Cost Segregation Proposals
Compare STR cost segregation proposals by the assignment each firm will perform, the evidence it will use and the work your CPA must do afterward. Send the same factual property file to every provider. Differences in purchase basis, furnishings or timing assumptions can create very different projections before methodology is considered.
Define the assignment in one paragraph
Identify the property and owner, acquisition or construction event, rental use, earlier depreciation and later projects. State whether the quote should cover a building acquisition, a renovation or a limited set of improvements. Ask the firm to list exclusions and unresolved inputs. Keep that assignment with every proposal.
Distinguish three work products
- Preliminary estimate: assumptions used to discuss possible scope or benefit; it is not the final component analysis.
- Study report: property-level findings, supporting cost and classification work, schedules and stated limitations.
- Return implementation: owner-level eligibility, elections, filing procedure, tax software entries and state adjustments determined by the responsible preparer.
Confirm which products are included and who is responsible for the rest. A firm may provide more than one, but a study fee should not be assumed to include every related tax service.
Turn marketing terms into written responsibilities
| If a proposal says… | Request clarification |
|---|---|
| Engineering-based | Who prepares and reviews the work, and which property records support it? |
| Remote study | Who collects evidence, what areas are documented and how are gaps resolved? |
| CPA-ready | Which schedules are delivered and how does your preparer use them? |
| Audit support | What assistance, duration, exclusions and additional fees are in writing? |
| Fast delivery | When does the clock begin, and what happens if required records are incomplete? |
| Large first-year benefit | Which costs, dates, rates and owner-level assumptions produced the estimate? |
Compare the complete engagement price
Record study fees, travel or rush charges, revisions, support and separately engaged implementation. Stratum charges $1 per square foot with a $2,000 minimum per property. Do not compare that amount with a competitor’s starting price unless the property, product and included work match.
Keep the proposed tax benefit in a separate column from the contract price. Your preparer should evaluate the incremental deduction and its usability before it is described as savings. Use the fee-versus-assumed-benefit worksheet for transparent arithmetic.
Ask for a relevant report example
Request a redacted example suited to your property type. Can you identify the property scope, cost reconciliation, component schedule, methodology and limitations? The IRS audit guide discusses these report considerations, but referencing it is not provider certification. Review the report acceptance guide with your CPA.
Make a decision with the open questions visible
Download the provider comparison worksheet. Enter each firm’s written answer and source date. Mark unanswered questions rather than inferring a promise. Resolve material scope differences before selecting a provider.
Our STR firm selection guide addresses choosing a provider; this page helps normalize actual proposals. Both are published by Stratum, a competing provider, rather than an independent rating service. Browse source-backed provider guides for questions to take into the quote process.
Primary references and review limits
Sources checked October 28, 2026. Use the applicable year and your own facts with a qualified tax professional. This educational material does not establish a deduction or guarantee a tax result.